The study
One destination measured: the Bay of Mont-Saint-Michel
10 traveller questions — family, budget, romantic weekend, group, guest house, wheelchair access — put to 3 AI assistants, three times each. 90 answers, in French, English and German. We counted every property named.
Perplexity Sonar
« Je cherche un hébergement pour 6 personnes autour du Mont-Saint-Michel en août »
Sources read by the AI
- gitesdefrance35.com
- airbnb.fr
- ot-montsaintmichel.com
- booking.com
- gites-de-france.com
Not one property's own website. The AI reads only platforms and the tourist office.
ChatGPT
« Existe-t-il des chambres d'hôtes de caractère dans la baie du Mont-Saint-Michel ? »
Sources read by the AI
- les-demeures-de-mont-dol.fr
- chambre-hotes-mont-st-michel.com
- gites-de-france.com
- auptitmont.fr
- ot-montsaintmichel.com
On niche questions, individual properties finally surface. That is where it is won.
Claude Sonnet 4.5
« Hôtel de charme près du Mont-Saint-Michel pour un week-end en amoureux ? »
Sources read by the AI
- booking.com
- pagesjaunes.fr
- tripadvisor.com
- manoir-rochetorin.com
- lemsm.com
Six properties named in a single answer — and the same six come back everywhere.
What makes hotels different
A traveller is not looking for a hotel, they are looking for a stay. "With
the family", "cheap, under 15 minutes away", "with a good restaurant",
"wheelchair accessible". These are questions a booking platform answers poorly
and an AI answers very well — by naming two or three properties.
Our measurement surfaces two things.
AIs read platforms and editors, not hotel websites. Booking, the tourist
office, TripAdvisor and three travel blogs account for most of the sources
consulted. A property's own site only appears once questions get specific.
But they name places, not platforms. The most-cited property in the bay is
named twice as often as Booking. Which means the ground can be taken — provided
you exist inside what the AIs read.